One of the Pitfalls of being a writer...

I'm a very big fan of George R.R. Martin. I read A Game of Thrones back in 1998 and have been a loyal reader of his books ever since. The entire series is so well written and has taken the fantasy genre into directions that had not really been done before. His need to make his world have a sense of realism--no fairies or elves in this world, just the occasional dragon--truly drew readers including myself into his world. With the HBO series, he has gained many new fans and readers.

Sadly some of his decisions in where the story has gone so far has cost him readers and viewers.  Events that have happened to fan favorites, especially the Stark family, have caused some fans to express anger and outrage. Some fans have stated they won't watch the show anymore, nor read the books. Last night's episode which depicted the tragic Red Wedding is a prime example.

I remember year ago reading that scene for the first time. I knew that Walder Frey would try to get some kind of revenge on Robb for not marrying his daughter; but then it seemed all had been forgiven. When the slaughter began I--like everyone--was shocked at the revelation. How could the kill Robb and Catelyn? The war in the North was over, just like that? It was as much of an emotional experience to read as it was to watch.

But what I didn't do was complain. I saw it for what it was. A reminder that the world is not always fair, and the good guys do not always win. We wanted the son to avenge the father, and we all thought that would happen; now that dream is done. So where will that lead us next?

I don't wish to give away too much to those who have not read the books, but this not the end for the Starks. Remember, Bran and Rickon are still alive and well though they are on the run. As are the two sisters Sansa and Arya. even Jon Snow may still be a factor in the Stark legacy.

Martin in interviews has even stated that he hated writing that part, as it was like murdering his children. Any writer will tell you that their characters are like their children; we spend so much time developing them and investing in them that letting them go can be extremely difficult. While his choice may not have been popular with some of his fanbase, I applaud his amazing storytelling.

While some have fallen away from the killing off of characters they liked, others stay firm in their love of the series.There are so many complex stories and interweaving revelations that continue to keep my interest. I for one look forward to book six, which will hopefully be coming soon.

It's a challenge for any writer. Do you give the audience what they want and expect? Or do you give them something unexpected that may shock them? Careful readers can even get a hint of foreshadowing if the writer is truly skilled, details the audience may only pick up on over a  second reading. I praise a good twist that changes the story and keeps the reader guessing.

Unless he kills of Tyrion. Then I may have to change my mind.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

National Novel Writing Month

 So next week starts National Novel Writing Month (or NANOWRIMO or NANO). The idea for those who may not know is that you give yourself the challenge of writing a 50k word novel in a month. The official start date is Nov 1st with the goal of being done by the end of the month. I have done it for a couple of years now, and it is a great way to get the first draft of a novel written. If nothing else, it builds great writing habits.  Some people set some pretty lofty goals, like trying to write a novel in one day. To me, that just seems like unneeded stress and chances of having 50k words of garbage to have to go back and heavily edit. Given, you won't have a polished novel doing NANO, but at least a serviceable first draft.  I have a few that I have done, that I am in the process of going back and editing. I hate editing though. I always feel like I should be working on the next project. But, it is part of the process and editing and revision are important to make a book th...
Read more

Plugging Along

 I started National Novel Writing Month strong this year. I hit my word count every day in the first week. But as always, work and life have started to slow me down. I'm still working on writing every day, though I am falling behind on my word count. As of right now, I will be finished with this draft beginning of December. Plus I still have a couple works in progress that I need to work on.  On the upside, I did self-publish one of my first NANO books, " Paradise of the Locusts " this month. You can find it on most ebook providers. It should be available on Amazon Kindle soon. After doing research and getting feedback from people in my writing groups, I think self-publication is the way to go for now. While I still have the dream of traditional publication, I also know that it can be difficult. Finding an agent to take up my work can be trying, as it is also subject to their own personal taste. But, if I self-publish and get some traction, who knows what will happen. The...
Read more

My thoughts on Fuerguson and Beyond

I like many people have been following the case of Micheal Brown, the young man that was shot by Officer Darren Wilson. During the late hours of November 24, 2014 the Missouri grand jury decided not to indite Officer Wilson on several counts including murder down to manslaughter. The evidence that the jury investigated found no cause to put Wilson on trial, as it would appear he acted in self defense. Though my emotions ran high, I at first abstained from commenting on social media about the events for many reasons. However, as the media now is trying to make comparisons to the tragic shooting of a 12-year old boy in Cleveland has made me feel like I need to say my peace; and where else but my blog. lts start with Ferguson. Here is what we know, either from surveillance photos, statements, and forensic evidence (given I am taking some license to create a cohesive narrative).  Mr. Brown and a friend walked into a convenience store where he stole a pack of Swisher Sweet cigars (yes...
Read more